SNAP SHOT PRESS RELEASE | A GIFT OF THE MAGI

ALL IMAGES BY Michael Brosilow

What would you give up to spark joy in the ones you love?

It's a loaded question, but to be confronted with it has to make you think, what do you truly have to offer? Is it a tangible good, a piece of your identity, an unspeakable task, or a priceless act? Could you? Would you? Have you?

[Should you?]

Saturday’s [November 14th, 2026] Milwaukee Chamber Theater’s opening night performance of A GIFT OF THE MAGI was a heart warming reminder of why material things are distractions to what truly matters; love through the practice of humanity. Now before you clock me for being an over emotional theater critic, consider how art [in all its forms] should provoke a reaction out of you, and as we enter the season of giving. I am giving myself permission to be less subtle…What a gift! As the stage is set with clothes lines, and wood planks, simple furnitings and the strings of the cello & violin played by Sky Yela and Susan Nicholson respectively, we are whisked into the turn of the century New York, a scathing economy and holiday season that is running on pennies. With neighborly-like whimsy, Jonathan Gillard Daly pays O. Henry as he narrates our story of Della [Jamie Mercado] & Jim [Dimonte Henning] obsessing over their mutual want to gift each other something meaningful for Christmas.

But how? Jim has recently had a massive pay cut, and Della is finessing at her finest to make that $20 a month work for that household budget. She has bartered with the butcher, the produce vendor, and even with herself on what is needed, what can wait, and what is a luxury [Listen she almost talked herself out of getting butter to cook the holiday meal. . . it's giving bland!]. But it was how Mercado pulled those invisible coins out of nowhere to pay for a little bit of this and a little bit of that, to make the math math that was so convincing. How many of us in today's economy have tried to stretch the budget beyond means to put a smile on a loved one's face? And Henning's glee as he sang about his “Dell” was just as reminiscent, of the little flickers of joy that someone who makes your daily life just a little bit kinder, softer, sweeter, in a world where chaos can strike as soon as you step out your front door, is all you need to keep you going.   

So let me not bury the lead, both so sure that they need to show how appreciative they are of each other but their most praised possessions are on the line [his watch & her hair]...

Pause…the wig! Laid, slayed and very convincing with bundles down her back. Brava!

…Where we see them struggle to find the money, they offer up things that, in the world, will not be held sacred, in the way they were sacred to them, to get the funds they seek. So is it worth it?

The question I ask again is. . . is money ever the real solution to the problem. As humanity keeps reminding us, that the bonds we have with each other, are the bonds that will sustain us, keep us going for another day [& sometimes a lifetime]. And as I sat in that theater, unsettled at how fast the holidays have approached, I teared up a bit at the thought of the things that I had given up in life just to see someone I loved smile or to get them the “gift” I thought they needed to feel whole. It was quite foolish because nothing could sustain those types of burdens forever. 

And then, there is the music break. In a moment that feels almost suspended in time, Sky Yela asks if they can play Jim something. What follows is more than a musical interlude; it is a carefully curated and directed experience that creates space for something we don't always allow ourselves to feel: collective hope. The tune becomes a communal pulse, a gentle reminder that even when life has dealt us an unfair hand, there is still something worth holding on to. Did I wish that this moment would have inspired Jim not to sell his watch? Absolutely! [Giving up a legacy is forbidden]. But perhaps that would have missed the point. The win is that, for a moment, Jim is reminded not to lose hope. And the way he runs off into the distance, energized by a new sense of possibility, feels just as intentional as the music itself. What makes the moment even more generous is the awareness that the audience is there, too. We are not simply watching Jim receive a little hope; we are being offered some ourselves. That is the beauty of live theater when done well; it recognizes that the people sitting in the dark have their own burdens, their own disappointments, and their own reasons for needing a reminder that tomorrow can still be better.

Maybe in that we find the purpose of the A GIFT OF THE MAGI, the wise understand that hope, not material possessions, is the thing that sustains us. It is what keeps us human when our good deeds go unrewarded, when the world becomes a little more beastly than it needs to be, and when the weight of simply getting through another day threatens to darken the light we carry that is the vessel of our love. Della and Jim's sacrifices may be wrapped in the language of material things, but their meaning lives somewhere much deeper. And that is where this production finds its heart. It reminds us that generosity does not have to leave us depleted, that love should not require us to disappear into the things we give away, and that sometimes the most meaningful thing we can offer another person is the reassurance that they are not alone. It is a beautiful reminder, particularly as we enter the holiday season, to consider what it might mean to give something back to ourselves, too. To share a love that is untethered from material things, that does not come with a price tag or require us to prove our worth through sacrifice. So, as you make your lists, wrap your presents, and prepare to show the people in your life just how much they mean to you, I leave you with this: What would you give up to spark joy in the ones you love? And perhaps the more important question is, what could you give without losing yourself in the process?

Lexi S. Brunson  | Editor-in-Chief /CW